5 Differences Between Bison Ribeye vs Beef Ribeye for a Tasty Steak Choice

Are you a steak lover that’s always on the hunt for the juiciest, most flavorful cut of meat? Well, look no further than bison ribeye and beef ribeye. Both mouth-watering options are popular among meat enthusiasts, but which one reigns supreme?

In this article, we’ll compare and contrast the taste, nutritional value, and cooking methods of bison ribeye vs. beef ribeye to help you decide which is better for your next gourmet meal. Get ready to sink your teeth into some serious, meaty goodness!

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

What Is Bison Ribeye?

Bison ribeye and beef ribeye are both cuts of steak that come from the ribs of the animals. Bison ribeye is cut from the ribs of a bison, while beef ribeye is cut from the ribs of a cow. Both cuts of meat are well-marbled and have a lot of flavors.

So, which is better? It depends on your personal preference. Some people prefer the taste of bison, while others prefer beef. More people have tasted beef than bison. So, if you’ve never tried bison, you may want to start with beef and then try bison to see which you like better.

What Is Beef Ribeye?

A beef ribeye is a cut of meat that comes from the rib area. The rib area of the cow is located between the shoulder and the neck, and it is one of the most flavorful cuts.

A ribeye steak is usually cut from the center of the rib roast, and it can be either boneless or bone-in. A boneless ribeye steak will have more fat than a bone-in steak but will also be more tender.

The Differences Between Bison and Beef Ribeyes

Both types of red meat taste similar and are low in carbs. One of the main differences between the two kinds of meat is that bison comes from buffalo, and beef comes from cows. When it comes to choosing between bison and beef ribeyes, there are a few key differences that you should know.

Another significant difference between bison and beef meat are the diets of each animal. For one, bison is a leaner meat than beef, so it has less fat and calories. Additionally, bison is a grass-fed animal, while most cattle are grain-finished.

That means the bison meat is higher in omega-3 fatty acids and antioxidants. Both are also lean cuts and full of protein, iron, and zinc. So eating bison and beef in moderation will help sustain a healthy diet.

Bison offers a richer taste, while beef offers more marbling fat, creating a juicy steak. Finally, bison has a naturally sweet flavor, while beef has a more savory or gamey taste. Ultimately, the choice between bison and beef ribeyes comes down to personal preference.

Bison meat is growing in popularity, causing some farmers to feed their buffalo grain instead of grass to keep up with the demand for that particular meat. However, you can still find grass-fed bison and beef in local grocery stores.

In the U.S., grass-fed meat is more expensive than grain-fed, which some who like a tender taste may find not worth it.

Which One Is Better? 

Whether the animal is grass or grain-fed, both types of meat can be part of a healthy diet. And both bison ribeye and beef ribeye are delicious. So which one is better? Well, everyone’s taste buds and preferences are different, but here’s a detailed comparison of the two.

Bison Ribeye

• Bison meat is leaner than beef, so it’s healthier.
• It also has fewer calories than beef.
• Bison meat has a richer flavor than beef.
• Bison ribeyes are usually more expensive than beef ribeyes.
• Bison has more protein, but not much more.
• Bison has more zinc.

Beef Ribeye

• Beef is more tender than bison.
• Beef has a more mild flavor than bison.
• Beef ribeyes are usually less expensive than bison ribeyes.
• Beef has more fat, including saturated fat.

How to Cook a Bison or Beef Ribeye

When it comes to cooking a bison or beef ribeye, there are a few things you need to keep in mind. First, you need to make sure that the meat is properly thawed. If you try to cook frozen meat, it will not cook evenly and will likely be tough and dry. Second, you need to choose the right kind of cooking method.

Grilling, broiling, and pan-frying are all great options for cooking ribeye. Just make sure you don’t overcook the meat; otherwise, it will be tough and dry. Finally, let the meat rest before cutting it. This process allows the juices to redistribute throughout the steak, making for a juicier and more flavorful steak.

Ultimately, the decision between bison ribeye and beef ribeye is up to you. Both meats are delicious and deliver a tasty flavor, texture, and mouth-watering aroma when cooked correctly.

Depending on your tastes and preferences, either option can be a great choice for any special occasion or just an ordinary dinner night at home!

More FAQs

Is bison ribeye better than beef?

Bison ribeye is a healthier choice compared to beef as it is leaner and can help reduce calorie and fat intake. With nearly 25% fewer calories and lower levels of total and saturated fat, bison offers a more nutritious option (2, 3). Furthermore, the lower fat content of bison results in finer fat marbling, resulting in meat that is softer and more tender.

Is bison ribeye tender?

Bison ribeye is indeed tender, delivering a richer and sweeter flavor compared to beef. Our Master Butchers hand-cut the ribeye, ensuring its quality. Additionally, this cut contains more marbling than other bison steaks, resulting in an irresistible taste that makes it perfect for grilling. For optimal results, it is recommended to cook the bison ribeye at low temperatures.

What tastes better beef or bison?

Beef and bison have distinct flavors, but when comparing the two, bison tends to offer a lighter and more delicate taste. Some even describe bison as having a slightly sweeter flavor. Additionally, bison meat is known for its high iron content, which contributes to a unique and somewhat earthy or mineral-like taste. It’s important to note that this flavor is not overpowering, and bison does not have a gamey taste at all.

What is the healthiest red meat?

The healthiest red meat is pork, specifically lean options like pork loin, tenderloin, and center cut chops. Additionally, leaner cuts of steak such as flank, round, sirloin, tenderloin, and ball tip are also good choices. Ground meat options include chicken, turkey, pork, and beef.

What is the best cut of bison steak?

The best cut of bison steak is either the shortribs or the skirt steak. These two cuts are highly desired due to their tender and flavorful qualities. When braised for a few hours, the shortribs become incredibly tender, with the meat easily falling off the bone. Similarly, the skirt steak offers a delightful taste and texture.

Is bison a good substitute for beef?

Bison is a great substitute for beef due to its mild flavor and significantly lower fat and cholesterol content. It is now readily available in supermarkets nationwide and offers a much leaner option compared to beef. For instance, a 3-ounce portion of cooked beef (trimmed) contains approximately 9 grams of fat, whereas bison is considerably leaner.

Are bison ribeyes good?

Bison ribeyes are indeed good. Our Delmonico steak, sourced from the primal rib section of bison, is exceptionally tender and boasts a generous marbling that enhances its flavor. This cut is highly favored by steak enthusiasts for its succulence and rich taste.

Is bison steak better than beef steak?

Bison steak is healthier than beef steak due to its lower calorie and saturated fat content. The relative proportion of unsaturated to saturated fats in bison meat is better for overall health, particularly heart health. Additionally, bison meat is higher in protein compared to beef.

Does bison meat taste like beef?

Bison meat does taste similar to beef but with a slightly sweet undertone that distinguishes it. It can easily rival the flavor of the best steak or burger you’ve ever had. Unlike certain specialty meats, bison is not gamey, and regardless of how you cook it, it remains incredibly tender.

Is bison ribeye better than prime ribeye?

Bison ribeye is superior to prime ribeye in terms of nutritional value. Across all cuts, buffalo meat has lower calorie and fat content, while being higher in protein compared to beef. A serving of bison ribeye weighing three to four ounces contains 177 calories, 6 grams of fat, and 30 grams of protein. In contrast, a typical beef ribeye has 265 calories, 17 grams of fat, and 27 grams of protein.

Does bison make good steaks?

Bison steaks can vary in fat content, ranging from reasonably fatty to ultra lean. While fat marbling is uncommon, the flavor is rich without being greasy. The fat, which is often yellow due to the grass-fed diet of the animals, has a less creamy texture compared to grain-finished beef.

Why is bison meat so expensive?

Bison meat is more expensive than beef due to the difference in supply and demand, as there are fewer bison available compared to cattle. The extensive presence of large-scale cattle farming across the country makes farmed beef more affordable in comparison.