Is Alligator Gar Good to Eat? Taste & Cooking Tips Explained

Alligator gar, a large freshwater fish found in the South, has a mild, chicken-like taste and firm texture, making it popular for dishes like stews and jambalayas.

what does alligator gar taste like

If you have been in the South, you might have seen a strange fish on the menu. Alligator gar looks like an ancient deep-sea monster, with rows of sharp teeth and a long, broad snout. These fish can be huge and live in lakes and rivers in Louisiana, Texas, and Mexico. However, what does alligator gar taste like? 

An alligator gar might seem strange and dangerous, but people often catch and eat it in the Southern states where it is native. The taste of a filet of alligator gar compares favorably to other popular gamefish (like catfish) for its mild and soft meat. 

However, the alligator gar has some specifications. You should never eat the skin, as it’s full of natural toxins. There are certain ways to clean and cook alligator gar, so it’s crucial to have a knowledgeable chef prepare the gar. Here is a guide to alligator gar, its taste, and where to find it. 

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

What Is Alligator Gar?

Alligator-Gar_1208635

Alligator Gar is the largest fish in the gar family and one of the only freshwater fish breeds that can exceed 100 pounds.

As an adult, it averages about 150 pounds and is six feet long. However, the longest reported alligator gar was almost 10 feet long and weighed over 300 pounds. 

Gar is a thin, long fish with a snout and rows of teeth. These features got the alligator gar, the largest in the family, its name and its reputation.

Alligator gar have many features of their mammalian and amphibian ancestors and share characteristics with ancient fish. 

Alligator gar are the largest breed of freshwater fish in America and live in the Southeastern United States and the rivers and bays of Mexico.

Most commonly found in Louisiana, Texas, Florida, and Mexico, this fish is a popular local dish as long as you prepare it correctly. 

Alligator gar tends to pick up toxins from the water around it and hold them in its skin. Therefore, there are places where it’s illegal to fish and eat gar because the fish could be poisonous.

So..can you eat alligator gar? Yes! The alligator gar is safe to eat as long as it has been sourced from clean water. 

What Does Alligator Gar Taste Like?

Alligator gar is a unique experience for fish eaters. If you’ve had regular gar, alligator gar tastes very similar, with a touch less fishy flavor.

The key point of alligator gar is that it has a very mild flavor on its own and works well with spices and other flavorings. 

Alligator gar has a texture more like chicken than “regular” fish meat. It doesn’t taste very “fishy” and doesn’t have the flakiness that most freshwater fish do.

Instead, this fish tastes a little more like alligator meat. It is a distant relative of the alligator, so it makes sense. 

These unique flavors and textures come from the ancient roots of the alligator gar. Unlike many fish cousins, the gar family has evolved very little from its ancestral form.

It’s a relative of alligators and crocodiles, which gives its meat a more gamey texture

Why Do People Eat Alligator Gar?

Alligator gar is eaten in the South for several reasons. The first reason is that it tastes good. The flesh is mild and white, with a similar taste to many other sports fish. Many people eat alligator gar for the taste. 

Of course, anglers in the South are experts at eating what the lakes and bayous provide. Alligator gar provides a lot of meat in every fish, which makes it worthwhile to hunt and catch these enormous fish. 

Although gar is hard to catch, it is big enough to make it worth it. Where it’s legal, and there isn’t a gar ban, the alligator gar is a popular option for stews, jambalayas, and fried fish plates. If you add some seasoning – and you’re set.

Where Can You Find Alligator Gar?

Alligator Gar Habitat Range
Source – USGS

Alligator gar only lives in the southeastern United States and Mexico. You can catch it in rivers, ponds, and lakes along the states that line the Gulf of Mexico but you rarely see it elsewhere. 

If you want to try some alligator gar, a seafood or Cajun restaurant in Louisiana, Texas, or Mississippi might be your best bet. Although it’s not usually on the menu, you might be able to find it in restaurants further north or further east. 

Gar is difficult to catch and takes some preparation. The skin absorbs toxins from the water and can be deadly, so cutting and cooking the fish properly is crucial.

When ordering garfish, make sure it’s from a quality chef or restaurant with experience with the fish. 

Frequently Asked Questions about Alligator Gar

Here are some frequently asked questions about alligator gar and their answers. Hopefully, they will help to answer your questions! 

Is alligator gar good eating?

Alligator gar is delicious when prepared well. It has all the health benefits of fish but the texture and consistency of chicken. Usually, gar pairs with spices and vegetables to add some flavor. 

Why do people not eat alligator gar?

Some people don’t eat alligator gar, largely because the fish are very difficult to catch. While the skin can be toxic in some places, state laws prevent anyone from fishing there. Otherwise, the alligator gar is safe to eat. 

Does gar taste like lobster?

Gar is often compared to lobster because it has a unique texture. Gar isn’t quite fishy and doesn’t quite have the same texture as land mammals, so it can have a similar taste to eating lobster. Both are good when covered in butter. 

Are alligator gars good to eat?

Alligator gars are good to eat as their flesh is white and firm, with a mild taste similar to that of various sport fishes commonly consumed by anglers. The fact that commercial fisheries exist for alligator gar in certain southern states is evidence of its popularity as a table fare.

Will alligator gars bite you?

Alligator gars are not known to bite humans, although they are still feared by many. These massive fish are typically slow and calm, making them less aggressive towards people. For instance, their feeding habits can make them difficult to catch as they may be slow or hesitant in taking bait.

What is the best bait for alligator gar?

The best bait for alligator gar is typically carp, gizzard shad, smallmouth buffalo, and mullet. It is recommended to select the bait that is most prevalent in the specific fishing area. Gizzard shad and carp are generally the top choices for rivers and lakes.

Is garfish a good eating fish?

Garfish is a good eating fish due to its small size, sweet taste, and delicate flesh. However, some individuals tend to avoid them because they can be bony. If you are concerned about the bones, you can ask your fishmonger to butterfly them for you. Nevertheless, when cooked whole, Garfish flakes easily from the central bone structure, making it suitable for BBQ, grilling, or panfrying.

Is it safe to swim with gar?

It is safe to swim with gar as the teeth of the alligator gar are not meant for tearing prey into bite-sized pieces like sharks. Instead, they are designed for holding and subduing prey. Consequently, alligator gar only consume things they can swallow. The only potential danger posed by alligator gar is when anglers attempt to land and handle these large, powerful fish.

Is a gar fish a bottom feeder?

A gar fish is considered a bottom feeder as it primarily feeds on other fish and invertebrates that reside near the bottom of bodies of water, such as the alligator gar.

What part of gar is poisonous?

The part of gar that is poisonous is their eggs, which can be toxic to humans, birds, and other mammals, even though the flesh of gars is safe to eat.

Is it safe to swim with alligator gar?

It is safe to swim with alligator gar as they do not pose a threat to humans and there have been no recorded attacks on people. However, it is important to note that the fish’s eggs are poisonous if consumed by humans. This toxicity serves as a defense mechanism against predators like crustaceans.

Why do gar smell so bad?

Gar smell bad because they are slimy and stinky, which is mostly true. The sliminess and strong odor of gars serve as a protective mechanism, allowing them to be more hydrodynamic and evade predators from above and below. The pungent smell of gars is particularly noticeable, and it can vary among different species and be influenced by their environment and diet.

What will gar bite on?

Gar will bite on live, 4- to 6-inch-long shiners for bait, and they are typically rigged on a 5/0 to 6/0 treble hook tied six inches below a bright orange, 4-inch-diameter bobber.

What is the biggest gar caught in America?

The biggest gar caught in America is a gar caught in Mississippi weighing 327 pounds, which holds the world record. These fish, known for their large size, can grow up to 8 feet long and weigh over 300 pounds, although this is uncommon. They are found exclusively in North and Central America.

What is special about an alligator gar?

An alligator gar is special because it is one of the largest freshwater fishes, reaching lengths of up to 3 meters (10 feet) and weighing up to 127 kilograms (279 pounds). They have a varied diet, including live and dead fish, crustaceans, insects, and frogs. Adult alligator gar either stalk their prey or patiently wait for it to pass by. Additionally, they are oviparous, meaning they lay eggs.

Can you eat alligator gar in Florida?

Alligator gar can be eaten in Florida, but it is important to handle them with caution and ensure proper cleaning before consumption.

Why is it called alligator gar?

The species is called alligator gar due to its physical resemblance to the alligator, evident in its long body and snout, as well as its row of sharp teeth. However, unlike the alligator, the gar possesses fins that aid in its underwater swimming abilities.

What is the best bait for gar in Florida?

The best bait for gar in Florida can be either minnows or artificial lures. Live bait options consist of minnows and cut bait, while artificial lures include spinners and spoons. Anglers have a range of methods at their disposal to catch Florida Gars, such as spin casting, trolling, drift fishing, bait casting, and fly fishing.

Final Thoughts

Alligator gar is a unique find in the southern United States because of its size and how difficult it can be to catch. However, if you’re lucky enough to see it on the menu, you might want to try it. Alligator gar is a remnant from another era and one of the only fish with a meat-like texture and taste. 

Similar Posts